Monday, March 3, 2014

The Poor, Stupid Habits, and Satire

This is blog #4 out of 8. Welcome to my halfway point. I have chosen another article about poverty and satire, and I will analyze it much like my previous blog posts. However, before we dive into the article, I'd like to sidetrack and give everyone a few laughs with this video. Be warned, it's not the best quality, but the message is pretty spot-on and hilarious. Enjoy.
"So they charged me 15 dollars. That's what it costs to only have 20 dollars". - Louis CK

Now that we've all had a laugh and agreed that being poor is expensive, let's take a look at my next article focus - the poor and stupid habits.

The article I chose for this blog was also found on Cracked.com and is titled The 5 Stupidest Habits You Develop Growing Up Poor by John Cheese. (I might have a literary crush on this author and website. Something about it really pulls on my humorstrings). I really like this article because it is funny, and sheds light on a few habits that people who haven't grown up poor have probably never considered.

#5: You Develop a Taste for Shitty Food
Cheese makes the point that when you don't have very much money, you're not exactly purchasing food based on quality, per se. You're buying foods that are cheapest and have the longest shelf life. Well, unfortunately, those two criteria are setting the bar pretty freaking low when it comes to health food standards. The point is made that when you're really poor you're more than likely doing your grocery shopping once a month whenever your food stamps are renewed. This is because taking multiple trips to the grocery store wastes money on gas or bus fare. So, think about how many times you've thrown away fresh produce because it has gone bad. A bag of lettuce here, an apple there, a few tomatoes, and that bag of potatoes that you left under the sink that has practically sprouted legs and tried to run away on its own. When you're poor you don't have the luxury of throwing away rotten produce. (Glamorous, right?) You're buying canned foods because they are MUCH cheaper and will expire exactly one day before never. You probably didn't realize what a fancy-pants spinach eater you were when you unloaded your last bag of grub from the grocery store.

Well - here's a fun fact that Cheese points out. He says that people who have never been poor love to point at overweight people and sarcastically talk about how they are clearly not missing any meals. So, I like to make fun of fat people just as much as the next guy, but for giggles lets look at the facts about eating cheap unhealthy food and try to figure out it's connection to obesity. TV dinners, fast food, canned and boxed goods tend to have a way higher amount of processed ingredients, salt, sugar, you name it. If the doctor said that you should cut back on your intake of it, it is probably one of the main ingredients in the affordable meal you are about to partake in. Well, poop. Even better, after you grow up eating this crap, making the transition into fresh food isn't that exciting. It's not that the food is bad, it's just different, and doesn't bring back the nostalgic taste of the culinarily exquisite experience of a good old box of Kraft Mac & Cheese.
I can only assume that the advertisement above is targeting cardiologists everywhere and the paychecks they will receive after removing plaque from the noodle shaped artery pictured here that appears to be crusted in Kraft cheese dust.

So, folks. What to do, what to do. Well, let's start with people who can't afford food. Food stamps will get you some groceries, but it is in fact a supplemental program. They actually don't even call them food stamps anymore - they are called SNAP benefits, which stands for Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program. Supplemental implying that the purpose is to supplement your assumed already existing supply of food. If you don't have this supply already in stock, then you are really forced to make those dollars stretch. Well, hit up some food banks! That's what they're there for! Yes. True. But when is the last time you visited a local food bank? I'll give you a few guesses what kinds of foods are available at your local food bank.

Oh come on. If you didn't guess the answer then you are really missing the point of my sarcasm. The answer is canned food, boxed food, frozen food, and other not-so-nutritious yet FDA deemed edible foods. The same cheap foods that have a really long shelf life that people in poverty are buying in the first place. It's a vicious cycle. What will it take to break the cycle? Money, probably. But in lieu of money, what can we do to increase the amount of healthy foods and fresh produce to the impoverished communities? There are a few programs out there that provide some produce to welfare recipients when it is in season. These programs are awesome! But they are only going on during the harvest season, and barely available in the city, so if you live in a rural area and don't have access to a car - forget it. Canned peas for life!

#4: Extra Money Has to Be Spent Right Goddamn Now!
The next segment addresses the fact that when you don't ever have extra money, you're not exactly sure how to use it when it does fall into your hands. Instead of saving or investing, there is this feeling of non-permanency that if the money isn't spent now, it will disappear in some other way without you having anything to show for it. So, instead of getting a leap on rent and bills, you now have a new TV and a  bobble-head of your favorite childhood pet. Because hey - the rent is paid this month baby and these former presidents can only high-five each other in my pocket for so long... they want to PARTY!
Pictured above: Washington and Lincoln as portrayed by sea turtles.

So, what are we going to do about it? What is a good way to kick these nasty spend-it-right-goddamn-now habits to move everyone into a more financially stable future? Well... let's start with budgeting. How many people are really good at budgeting their money? Here's a hint - if you run out of money every single month, you are probably not good at budgeting. But, here's the thing about budgeting - you need money to budget. I know. This vicious cycle crap is pretty vicious. And cyclic.

I think that out of all the useless classes I took in high school, budgeting could have probably replaced a whole bunch of them and I would have probably had some money to my name at age 25 that didn't have a negative sign in front of it. Simple skills could be taught like balancing a checkbook. (I still don't know how to do this. I blame online banking.) How about learning how to break down your budget using a simple budgeting tool to really project your expenses over a month? If you've ever done this, it is depressing. Depressing and USEFUL. If you can see where your money is going, then you can most likely prioritize where you money needs to go before you start spending your money on luxuries like fresh produce and a bobble-head of your favorite childhood pet.

#3: You Want to Go Overboard on Gift-Giving
The next part of this article talks about when you grow up getting very few gifts, you remember how bad that felt as a kid. So, you try to justify your own feelings on gift giving by going overboard for your own kids. This also fits in the scenario where you might be the crap gift giver to your children because you are poor, but the second you are slightly less poor - you're out to make it right and buy ALL the presents. Fair enough. I totally understand this. It makes a lot of sense that you felt beneath all of your friends as a child when they were shoving their super awesome toys in the back of their closets after Christmas to make room for their more super awesomer toys in the front of the closet, while you nervously brag about the even more awesome toy that your parents bought for you that you can't show your friend because it is imaginary. This leads to feelings of inferiority, which is a recurring theme in my blog and the general consensus is that it sucks. Feeling like you are less of a person than someone else for any reason, especially financial reasons, just feels terrible. So, why not take every opportunity to nip that nasty little feeling of sucky-ness in the bud and WAY overspend to make sure that the little shit next door with his little shit parents and his big shit toys aren't making your kid feel like an even smaller little shit this year.
Look at those four-eyed little shits. Sliming around your yard dressed as poop disguised as snails.

So how do we kick this spending problem? It seems easy, right? Don't spend more money on gifts than you can afford. Well, easier said than done. It's not so much a financial problem here as it is a psychological one. Feeling inferior or fearing that your children will feel inferior is a real concern, and one that any normal loving parent would never wish upon their spawn. I don't have a good answer for this one. My best suggestion would be to set a spending limit and choose wisely. However, I don't have children and I had some pretty awesome toys growing up, but that was way before Santa sold out and Apple merged with Christmas.

#2: You Become an Obsessive Bean Counter
On the flip side of points 4&3, your habits could be that you are very obsessive about counting the money that you have because you are always worried about going negative in the bank. And going negative in the bank only leads to bad things. It could lead to you getting your utilities shut off, a potential threat of eviction, and not being able to eat. Cheese's argument here is that even once you cross the threshold where you can stop counting pennies in the bank and roughly round off and know about where your finances are, you still worry. Constantly. It becomes a bad case of permanent financial anxiety. You know your bills are paid, there is food in the fridge, but you compulsively check your bank statement. You are probably suffering from PTSD (poor traumatic stress disorder). The side effects include bad dreams of time machines sucking you in and landing you exactly in the center of a poverty sinkhole. So, you wake up sweaty, fearful, and furiously rummage through all of your finances and start counting and saving EVERY PENNY. Once you reach the full effects of poor traumatic stress disorder, you eventually get to the point where you are really resenting those super generous always tipping 5% stingy jerks that are insistent on making you and the other people in your PTSD anonymous group feel cheap. How dare they.
Pictured above: poverty flashback

So, how are we going to make this habit better? I'm not so sure that worrying is such a bad habit. However, over-worrying is definitely a bad thing. And money is stressful.  I'm going to come back to my idea about budgeting classes and the basics of financial planning. I think it is an extremely useful skill-set that isn't as readily available as it should be. And when I say readily available, I mean that everyone who has access to any money or plans to have access to future money should learn how to budget it. So, in essence, my target demographic is the entire population. I think taking some valid information around financial planning would result in a lower stress level about your finances. If times are tough, it's going to be tough no matter how many planning tips you have saved away in the bank. But, knowledge is power and powerful people are usually rich.

#1: You Only Spend with the Short Term in Mind
In the final portion of this article, Cheese discusses the spending habits of people who grew up poor and how they trickle into adulthood and feed into the poverty cycle. Because there isn't a whole lot of money to spare, people are buying the bare minimum of what they actually need. Instead of buying the 2 pack of soap or deodorant, to save a extra couple bucks in the long run, they are only looking at prices and seeing either a $3 purchase or a $5 purchase, and 3 is less than 5, so the $3 purchase wins. This is true for all kinds of things, even things that you are going to eventually use like toilet paper, laundry detergent, and other necessities that don't necessarily have a shelf life. This is also true for larger, more expensive items. Cheese uses the example of a dryer, and how someone who doesn't have a lot of money won't go out and buy a dryer when they are having a clearance sale, because their dryer is still working (even if it is on its last leg). So, they wait until they have a dryer that doesn't work at all to go out and pay a premium price because they need a dryer and they need it NOW.
Pictured above: the rare but deadly currency consuming drying machine

There is very much a revolving theme to this article. And it's fitting that there is a photo of a money-hungry drying machine pictured here because it's pretty spot on in my comparison to vicious money sucking cycles that dry out your finances. (see what I did there?) If someone has enough money to buy in bulk to save in the long run, then they save in the long run. Ta-da! BUT, what if the person doesn't have enough money to do that? The smaller in size you tend to purchase things, the higher the price of the item per what you are actually getting. So, your bill might be smaller in the checkout line, but in the long run you are losing money. Again, I revert to financial planning and really knowing the ins and outs of budgeting and spending money. But what do I know? My greatest success this far in life is managing to supercede all of my ancestors in the race of who spent the most on their education, and if that wasn't a big enough win, I'm also the projected winner in the race of who's going to take the longest to pay off their debt. But I did stop at the store today and bought a tube of toothpaste, one stick of deodorant, and precisely two rolls of toilet paper for only $10. So suck it, person who now has 12 rolls of toilet paper, two tubes of toothpaste and three sticks of deodorant for $22. I spent $12 less than that you, so I've got that going for me. Suckers.

Again, thank you for reading. I look forward to your comments and ridicule.

Sunday, March 2, 2014

The Poor, Common Morals, and Satire

Hello again. Welcome to blog #3 of 8. If you've read my first two blogs, you know the drill. I'm going to pick an article revolving around poverty and satire, and provide my own hilariously insightful analysis.

The article that I chose for my third blogpost is 4 Common Morals Designed to Keep You Poor by John Cheese. This article was also found on Cracked.com. (sensing a theme, anyone?)

#4: Being Rich Makes You an Evil, Greedy Bastard
In this segment, Cheese makes the argument that there is a conception that if you are rich, you are an evil, greedy bastard. So, if you're wondering where Cheese got this inference, it is from every movie ever. Period. Rich = evil greedy bastards. The end. After giving this about .2 seconds of thought, I agree with this inference. Cheese notes that there is this notion that money corrupts people. It is not a desired thing because once you are rich, you are automatically a dick. It's the causality of said dickishness that Cheese argues. His point is that money doesn't corrupt you. If there wasn't any money, people would find the next most desired thing and fight over that.

However valid Cheese's point, he does delve deep into the psyche surrounding the notion of these rich, evil, greedy bastards. He says that it is so ingrained in our minds that wealth is an undesirable goal because too much money is a bad thing. This moral serves the purpose of warning the to-be rich of their future corruption, and also reassuring the non-rich that they should stay exactly where they're at. Because non-rich = non-evil greedy bastard.
Pictured above: the evilest, greediest bastard.

I question this moral slightly. Slightly. It is possible that I'm not completely on board with this idea because one day I might not hate being one of these evil, greedy bastards? Hmm... But I do agree that the portrayal of being rich or 'too rich' goes hand in hand with the portrayal of being an evil and greedy bastard. So, why is this? Is it that rich people have shit on poor people in the past or done some shady things that actually make them evil greedy bastards? Have they exploited others for their own personal gain? Is it fair to assume that because one super rich person is a super greedy, evil asshole that all super rich people are greedy, evil assholes? Maybe. But maybe not. Could this portrayal have possibly spawned from jealousy? I mean, how can you not be jealous of the super rich. Their only real problems are that everyone thinks that they are evil greedy bastards. I'll take that any day over a mortgage and loans that I can't afford. But as the old saying goes - you can't have your money and rub it in people's faces too. If you are rich, then you must have some flaw somewhere. Being ugly or sick just isn't enough. It needs to be a really deep internal flaw that no one will ever be able to spot in the non-rich, but everyone can see it in the super-rich. Yup. I see it. That's the unmistakable glowing aura of an evil, greedy bastard. I knew it!

#3: Haggling Over Debts Makes You a Dishonest Piece of Shit
Cheese explores debt in this segment. Ugh. Debt. Such a pesky and recurring topic. Cheese says that there's this idea that you are responsible for your own debt. Well, yeah, but... There is this common conception about feeling responsible for your debts and a duty to repay them at whatever interest rate you agreed to. Haggling over this interest rate and inflated amount owed makes you sound even poorer. Which is exactly the boulder chained to my ankle that I need when I'm already drowning in debt.
Excuse me. Sir? Sir. Could you kindly throw me that financial planning life raft? Oh, your feet are using it to prop themselves up? My mistake.

Cheese makes an interesting point that the rich don't seem to feel anything when they are haggling over debts or trying to compromise a lower amount of money owed. But somehow it just feels wrong and shitty if you really don't have the money to pay all of your debt. Cheese explores the truth that most loan companies will work with you to lower your debt a little or reduce interest rates and erase late fees. So why do the rich save money doing this while feeling nothing, and the poor who could really use a break pay premium debt balances and interest rates because we feel guilty about haggling? Well, I'm not sure. I've always felt that the rich have some leverage because hey, they're rich. I think this in particular when referencing any financial institution because if the rich have enough money at stake in that institution, then they get a bigger say on how their account is managed. However, if you've only got debt and no money (therefore no power, it seems), then what is your bargaining chip? How is it possible that the rich have lower interest rates than the poor who already can't afford whatever it is they need to purchase on credit? Sure, they have higher credit scores. They're rich. What did you expect? But doesn't it seem a little odd that we are giving premium interest rates to poor people who are already in debt and setting them up for failure? No? Well, ok then. Carry on, loan sharks.

#2: Asking for Help Makes You Weak
In this portion of the article Cheese looks at the way asking for help can hinder you. (and who would ever have unfair misconceptions about the poor? Oh, right). The hindrance comes at your from two angles, the internal and external. As if asking for help doesn't make you feel like a piece of crap on the inside, the people that you ask for help are probably judging you just as harshly. Or so it seems. Cheese says that when someone gives you something, it's all good and that person probably feels awesome about doing so. But when you ask for something, you could get a completely opposite reaction like you are some sort of leech looking for handouts. Cheese also argues that if you do need assistance from government programs, you should take it. If you are in poverty and you can't control all of the financial obligations around you, take the help. As much as you want to be self sufficient and not need it, you are only digging your hole deeper as you accrue more debt.
Well that wasn't easy! No. Not easy at all. In fact, it sucked. HARD.

So why is asking for help so difficult? Is it feeling inferior to those who are giving you help? Or are your own stereotypes keeping you from getting the help that you need to eventually not be in this situation anymore? Are you 'too good' for government programs? It's possible. Being in a spot where you literally can't afford to live definitely comes with it's own bag of feeling shitty about yourself, but how else will you get your life back on track? If you already can't afford your rent, bills, food, etc. then how will adding more expenses to continue living help you get out of debt? The answer is that it won't. It will get worse. Unless you win the lottery. Then good for you. But, on the off chance that you don't win the lottery - you need a plan to get ahead. So, my final question is which is worse: asking for help and possibly feeling like a shit-bag while you're climbing out of debt, or not asking for help and eventually getting your utilities shut off, evicted, and then having to ask for help? Personally, I'll take feeling like a shit-bag for a while over homelessness and on-the-fly 'I need money now' never-live-this-down kind of feeling.

#1: Saying No to Requests for Help Makes You an Asshole
In the final segment of this article, Cheese makes the argument that you can't give money to someone that you can't afford not to have in your own pocket. Seems reasonable, right? Well, it is easier said than done. It's hard to say no to someone's face when they have nothing and you do have the money they are asking for, even if you need it for something else. Especially family. But, Cheese makes a great point that by feeding into the circle of debt you are only digging yourself deeper. Only when you are able to stabilize your own finances and have extra left over, is when you will be able to loan money and not feel the deficit in the near future.
What? I printed this from the internet and it's signed by our president from seven years ago, so you know it's legit.

I don't think this one is that hard. But only in theory. Sure, it makes a lot of sense that you can't loan someone money you don't have. Even if you know you're going to need it. But if someone needs it more than you, and they're staring into your generous face with their stupid needy eyes, it can be pretty tough to say no. Especially if other people are watching. Then you have to come up with a lie because the truth that you really need that money and can't part with it implies that you too are financially unstable. And according to point #2, we can't have that, now can we?

Thanks for reading!

The Poor, Shady Laws, and Satire

Welcome to my second blog post. You are viewing #2 of 8, so by my calculation you are a quarter of the way there. (yeah, math!)

In this post, I will be addressing the article 5 Insane Laws Written Specifically to Harass Poor People that I found on Cracked.com. The Author of this article is J. F. Sargent. Much like my last blog post, I will review the article piece by piece, and then present my questions and thoughts for everyone to give thumbs up, thumbs down, ask questions, make comments, and most importantly air grievances.

#5. Unpaid Rent Can Get You Thrown in Prison in Arkansas
Sargent opens with the statement that if you are a normal person, you have most likely been late on your rent at least once. The law that Sargent is referring to is the failure-to-vacate law. This law states that if you're late on your rent, you have 10 days to get out. There is no investigation of this process so the landlord can basically say anything he or she wants and the tenant is at fault. Thinking about pleading not guilty? Seems reasonable, right? Well think again sane citizen, because pleading not guilty actually has worse consequences than pleading guilty. You still have to leave your home while you wait for a trial, and then pay all the court fees. Ahh, justice. Sweet corrupt justice. The system is so corrupt that actual homeowners have been charged with being late on their rent. Below is an example of what I envision that conversation to look like:
Judge: I can see how this is confusing to you, Mr. & Mrs. Homeowner. Allow me to explain: purple unicorns popcorn fluffy rug.
Mr. & Mrs. Homeowner: Well when you put it that way, I guess common sense and logic are completely disregarded in this situation. Thanks for the clarity.

Silver onion pickle powder. Yes, dishwasher candles, that's what I said the first time. Duh.

So, let's talk a little about this law. First off, wow Arkansas, you have really outdone yourself when it comes to making life tough for poor people and really exercising your right to make sure that no jail cells stay vacant. (I know, you're just looking out for the jail cells. Such lonely dwellings that whine and whine on hours end unless you find them some unjust company to play with. Alas.) Anyway - while I'm making fun of Arkansas, let's talk about state statistics and state mottos. According to Wikipedia, Arkansas is ranked #29 in size, #32 in population size, and #50 in lawmaker brain size. (ok, I might have made that last one up, but it's not my fault that Wikipedia lets anyone edit anything...) Their state motto is 'regnat populous' which roughly translates to 'the people rule'. Seriously? Which people? The rich ones? Maybe that's actually what it translates to. My Latin is about as good as the logic behind this law.

I'll open up some concluding thoughts about this law. Why is this still a law? If it is known that it is corrupt and generally speaking, stupid, then why hasn't anyone nixed it or edited it to make sense? What would happen if this were true in every state? Say you were late on your rent. So, now you need to spend money on storage space while you sit in jail waiting for trial. You obviously can't work while you're sitting in a jail cell, so how are you going to come up with the money for your back due rent, storage space, first month's rent and security deposit for a new place (assuming that you will eventually get out of jail) AND court fees? Sheesh! That's a lot of money for being put in jail for not having money in the first place. Oh, irony, you are a cruel mistress.

#4: Wisconsin Wants to Freeze the Bank Accounts of Unemployed People
Ok. Yeah. Let that one sink in for a second. So, don't jump out of your seat just yet to find the nearest map of the US and stick your middle finger right in Wisconsin's face. Not YET. When they want to freeze bank accounts of unemployed people, they mean people collecting unemployment. But when they see an error in your unemployment payments (wait, how is that my fault?), they want to reserve the right to freeze your bank account. The whole thing, not just the one unemployment payment that they screwed up. Apparently the method to the madness on this bright idea is that they will recoup money for the unemployment fund. Hmm... still wondering how this is your fault and now the state has frozen all of your funds on account of their screw up? You and me both, buddy.
At least I have work tomorrow and a paycheck on the way... Oh, wait.

Let's look at the logistics of this. I want to note that this isn't an actual law. It is what some legislators are pushing for. Even so, this is something that could very well be a reality. Let's hope that it doesn't come to that. I want to look at a scenario where this does happen to someone and let's see how successful this someone is. So, Suzie Someone loses her job. She is given unemployment benefits. Woo-hoo! Now she only gets 70-80% of what she was making. Boo-hoo, right? Only 70-80%? That's nothing. Well, perhaps not. If your salary is relatively low and you were struggling when you were barely making ends meet when you were receiving 100% of your salary.. that 20-30% cutback could lead to some serious problems. So now that Suzie Someone has received her first unemployment check that is not enough to pay her rent and bills on, she also is spending time looking for new jobs. Everything is going exactly as shitty as it sounds, when wait! What's this? Your bank account is frozen? But... what? Why? Oh... she was paid an extra $30 on one of her unemployment checks. Now she has to wait for the state to fix it, and who knows how long that could take. So, in the meantime she has no money, and no food. Oh, now it's the first of the month. She also don't have rent money.

This story ends in a tragic homeless, hungry, pissed off Suzie. As I predicted, not an ideal scenario. You may resume flipping the bird to the state of Wisconsin should you choose to do so.

#3: One Third of American States Have Debtors' Prisons
When I first read this I thought to myself 'what the hell is a debtors prison?' A quick google search confirmed my suspicion that it is exactly what it sounds like. Jail for people who can't pay their debts. Sargent talks about Charles Dickens and how he so eloquently expressed how much it sucks to be poor. He makes the incredibly valid and sane point that you can't earn the money to pay off said debt while sitting in jail.
Like, whoa, bro. Whoa. That's some deep shit right there.

Ok. Here's a fun fact about debtors' prisons. They were deemed illegal in the US in the 1830s. Yup. So, how do a third of states still have them? They get around calling it a debtors prison by holding people in contempt of court during a creditor lawsuit and then sending them to jail. Not paying your debt = contempt. How much do you have to owe? Apparently in Ohio there are some people doing time for as little as $300. I tried to find an accurate statistic about how many Americans are in debt, but everyone says something different and breaks it down according to this or that. My conclusion was that all of these sources gave roughly the same number- A LOT. A lot of people are in debt. I'm wondering how much money we as taxpayers are spending to house these people in jail whose only crime is being in debt along with the majority of other Americans. So, we're spending money to provide these people with shelter, food, medical care, and denying them a chance to work and earn money to pay off their debt. This makes perfect sense on opposite day. Personally, I should probably get an alias, a few wigs, and load some cash into a getaway bag. If they find out about my student loan debts... I'm toast.

#2: Tons of States Punish You for Being Homeless
Sargent lists different cities that target the homeless for crimes. For example, you can be arrested for scrounging for discarded food, panhandling, and falling asleep in public. The police have actually targeted the homeless and setting up essentially a sting operation to arrest these unfortunate folks. Surely, they have something better to do...
Excuse me Mr. Unfortunate Looking Person, but I'm going to need a receipt for those scraps.

Personally, I can't help but thinking that the homeless guy is making out in this situation. No one wants to be in jail, but hey a roof over your head, a shower, and three square meals a day don't sound so bad comparing to sitting on the street digging through trash cans waiting to be arrested. And no, before you get all crazy about my overly optimistic views on being in jail, I'm referring to a probably non-existent best case scenario where this guy spends a night or two and then goes back to his homeless. Either way, it doesn't look like a glamorous life. It seems like a complete and total waste of time for police to be targeting these people. If I'm ever in serious trouble and no one can come help me because they are setting up undercover operations to put the homeless in jail... then I don't know. That's stupid and crazy and I am speechless trying to define exactly how that would make sense in any variation of the universe.

#1: Tennessee Tries to Make Welfare Dependent on Kids' Grades
In his closing rant about laws that target the poor, Sargent notes that Senator Stacey Campfield has proposed a law that would make poor families' welfare benefits dependent on their child's grades. You might think this is a joke, but the good senator has actually revised this bill multiple times to try to get it passed. If this law did pass, poor families could lose up to 30% of their benefits if their children did not make 'satisfactory progress' in school. Sargent makes the point that there is a clear connection between poverty and education. But hey, that's his opinion. It's not like there's any research to support that.
Pictured above: actual research supporting the correlation between poverty and education.

So, here's a shocker! This correlation that I'm talking about is a negative one. When poverty increases, grades decrease. I know. Crazy. How could this be? Why aren't these poor kids excelling at the rate of all the rich kids? Well, a lot of them are coming from families that are undereducated. It's hard to teach your child what you don't know. Both parents could be working, leaving little to no time for helping their kids with school work. If there isn't enough money for food, then a child's growth (including brain development) could be stunted. Poor students often live in poor neighborhoods with poor schools, overcrowded classrooms, and an extreme lack of resources. But, Campfield knows how to fix this! Make them even poorer. That'll learn 'em.

I'm not a fan of even the slightest notion of this law, even as a joke. As I discussed in my first blog, when you cut benefits, it is often the children of the household that suffer. So, how are we supposed to help these children help themselves if they have no control over the household, and are likely facing this poverty and education barrier due to the fact that oh, I don't know, they're living in poverty? Nah. Couldn't be. It makes all too much sense to nurture these children who are doing poorly in school and try to make resources available to them. We should just punish them instead.

Thanks for reading! 

Sunday, February 23, 2014

The Poor, The Government, and Satire

This is one of eight blog posts that will address the poverty issue in America. I have decided to take a non-traditional stand in my blog while addressing these issues. I have decided to take a look at the satire surrounding the poor and try to derive some real meaning from these comic articles, pictures, and sound bytes. Why are these journalists writing about the impoverished? Is there any truth to their accusations and claims? I think there is. And whoever came up with the saying 'there is some truth behind every good joke', agrees.

The only difference between the Democrats and the Republicans is that the Democrats allow the poor to be corrupt, too. - Oscar Levant

For this first blog post I have decided to write about an article that I found particularly interesting and thought provoking that revolves around poverty and government.

The article that I'm going to be deriving from is 4 Things Politicians Will Never Understand About Poor People

I would like to discuss briefly and raise my own questions about the main points of the article.
#4: Poor Does Not Equal Unemployed
In the first segment of this article, John Cheese explores the statistical facts about the working poor. This article was written about a year ago, so the numbers are still pretty accurate. The author notes Newt Gingrich's idea to 'pay impoverished students to clean up vomit and strewn feces part-time at their schools' to earn money', and then leads into the hilariously accurate statement, 'Not to be out-douched, Mitt Romney's now famous video hit the 'net, showing him calling 47 percent of the country "entitled" and saying that they believe they're victims and they want the government to hand them everything:'
I hear he's running for the underinformed douchebag of the year. Finally! He was due for a win.

Cheese breaks down some facts for us. First, that 10.5 million Americans living in poverty are employed. That breaks down to be about a third of people in poverty. Now, I know what some of you skeptics are thinking. Big whoop. A third. That's like 33.3%, man. What are the other lazy 66.6% doing with our hard earned tax money? Well, friend, I'm glad you asked. Most of them are elderly or disabled. In fact, 91% of government benefits go to either the disabled, elderly, or working households. That's a pretty good statistic. In fact, an A-.

So, by my calculations, if 91% of the government benefits go to deserving (in my book) individuals, but 47% of the population are abusing government benefits and want everything for free, then I'm 89% sure that 78% of people have absolutely no idea what is going on with the government and the benefits that are distributed.

My question to you is how do we change this view of entitlements and the entitled? How do we further the knowledge of our well educated politicians to show that these benefits do in fact go to the deserving? (mostly). Or, how do we target the other 9%? Who are they? My guess is that most of them have applications in for disability or social security. Or - is this small potatoes? Do we just count this 91% A- as a win and move on? Surely, our focus could be shifted to an area of need. I mean, there must be something more attention worthy in the world of poverty than simply the people abusing it...

#3: Poor People are Not Mindless Leaches
In this segment, Cheese makes the argument that it is a common assumption that the poor are not educated and don't want to spend the time to become educated. Cheese throws out an interesting statistic that 47% (here we go again...) of impoverished 18-26 age group have been to college. College might not be the end-all be-all of smarts, but it does show some initiative, strive for further education and a better life, and most importantly, debt. Massive debt.

My thoughts on this are that I would really like to see the poverty levels once they start looking at everyone's net worth, not just their income. Sure, Sally Whoever makes $30,000 a year at her non-profit job, so she's a total $18,510 above 100% of the Federal Poverty Guideline. WOO-FREAKING-HOO!!!

But - what Sally Whoever doesn't get taken into account is that she has $140,000 in debt from her undergrad and Master's program, a rental payment of $800 every month, and a $500 car payment. Oh, and food. But first things first. She better pay off that interest on her student loans before she eats or she'll never be out of debt! *insert sound byte of loan companies everywhere laughing villainously*

So, just to stir the pot... what if we started taking into account everyone's net worth instead of their income? Or, this could go arguably south when we start talking about purchases people can't afford- 'what do you mean you bought a house? WHO NEEDS A FREAKING HOUSE IN THIS ECONOMY?' So I will back track and say what if we took into consideration people's student debt when calculating poverty. I only ask because I can tell you that my debt looks a lot more like a salary I strive to have someday than the impending doom disguised as 20-something normalcy.

#2: Poor People Aren't Rampant Drug Addicts
In the next rant, Cheese notes that when Arizona and Florida did mandate drug testing, they found that the population receiving government benefits is very clean. In fact, Florida lost a bunch of money spending the money to drug test people, and the people who were booted from the programs did not even come close to the money that went to drug testing everyone. Cheese also noted that even when people (albeit rarely) do test positive for drugs, they are probably not the ones suffering the most from the cuts. It's their children. Innocent children born into a world of poverty and even sadder a drug infested environment, now do not have access to food stamps or cash assistance or subsidies that make their day-to-day possible.
                                                         Pictured above: not a real thing.

My question to you all is what is the solution? I don't think that drug testing during the social security/disability application would be a bad idea. After all, you are getting doctors to sign off on your disability anyway. My second question is, do we deny drug addicts food stamps? Should we deny anyone food? I personally think that this is ridiculous. You can't exactly go to Giant Eagle and get three grocery bags full of ground beef and drugs, then check out with your EBT card and go home and get high and make tacos. It's just not how it works. Food stamps are to be used on FOOD. Even things that maybe would be good to include on the list of items that you can buy with food stamps ( Oh, say.. soap? Deodorant? The essential non-essentials) are not permitted to be purchased on your EBT card. Sure, people can sell their food stamps and buy drugs with the money... but that seems like a lot of work that should be policed by the actual police, not the underpaid and overworked staff at your local DPW office.

#1: You Don't Have Real Sympathy for the Poor if You've Never Lived It
The closing segment of Cheese's article explores how members of congress and other highly paid members of society try to identify with the poor. Cheese shows some quotes of people living 'paycheck to paycheck' or complaining about donating or paying taxes and how their take home pay is so minuscule. However, their salaries and take home pay FAR supersede that of people that the rest of us would consider to be pretty well-off. His point is that when they try to identify... they can't. They just can't. You can't complain about how expensive it is to keep up your houseS to a homeless person. To only have SO MUCH left over to live on does not register to a person who has NOTHING left over to live on except the rest of their unpaid bills growing until next payday.

My question on this (again) is how do we change this? What will it take to get a serious vote in government on poverty from a person who lives or has lived in poverty? How do we cross the barrier of stigma about the poor being uneducated when education costs so much that you practically have to be not poor to get it? What data and statistics (or are there any?) that will truly show those not in poverty what it is really like to live in poverty. Cheese also says that these people are getting their false notions about the undeserving poor from that story they heard one time about someone scamming the system. To that I say... 91%. With all the bad, let's give a round of enthusiastic high-fives to the 91% of government benefits doing exactly what they are supposed to do, which is helping poor people in need. 

Thanks for reading! Until next time...